Home › Food and Drink › Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant in Tampa

The 10 Best Italian Restaurants in Tampa (2026)

This ranking is built from Google review data and ordered by a Bayesian score that balances average rating with review volume, updated for 2026. We focused on businesses categorized as Italian on Google to highlight places that earn strong community feedback across Tampa. The list reflects the city’s spread of Italian options—from centrally located addresses to neighborhood corridors—so you can compare highly rated choices based on both score and how many diners have weighed in. Use this guide as a data-driven starting point when choosing an Italian meal in Tampa.

30 analyzed10 shortlisted4.7/5 average rating11,286 Google reviews

This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.

Are you a italian restaurant in Tampa?

People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.

✓ Live immediately  ·  ✓ One-time payment  ·  ✓ No subscription

10 of 10 spots still available

Our pick 2026

Pasta flame

4.9/5 · 1031 Google reviews · 10865 Cross Creek Blvd, Tampa, FL 33647

Pasta flame tops our list thanks to a near-perfect 4.9 Google rating combined with 1,031 reviews, giving it exceptional weight in a Bayesian ranking. That mix of a very high score and substantial review volume pushes it above other highly rated spots. The result is a pick that reflects both quality and broad community endorsement as measured on Google.

The full ranking

2

L’Amorino Italian Restaurant

6102 S MacDill Ave Ste a, Tampa, FL 33611 · website

L’Amorino Italian Restaurant holds a 4.9 rating with 192 reviews, categorized on Google as Italian and located on S MacDill Ave in Tampa.

4.9/5
192 reviews
3

La Terrazza Restaurant

1727 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605 · website

La Terrazza Restaurant carries a 4.8 Google rating based on 657 reviews and appears as Italian on Google, with an address on E 7th Ave in Tampa.

4.8/5
657 reviews
4

Che Vita

211 N Tampa St, Tampa, FL 33602 · website

Che Vita is rated 4.7 on Google from 419 reviews; the listing is Italian and the address on N Tampa St places it in downtown Tampa.

4.7/5
419 reviews
5

The Brother Trattoria

2402 S MacDill Ave, Tampa, FL 33629 · website

The Brother Trattoria shows a 4.7 rating with 364 Google reviews and is categorized as Italian, located on S MacDill Ave in Tampa.

4.7/5
364 reviews
6

Amaretto Italian restaurant Tampa

2501 W Tampa Bay Blvd, Tampa, FL 33607 · website

Amaretto Italian restaurant Tampa posts a 4.7 Google rating with 290 reviews, listed under Italian and found on W Tampa Bay Blvd in Tampa.

4.7/5
290 reviews
7

Spartaco’s Kitchen

241 E Davis Blvd, Tampa, FL 33606 · website

Spartaco’s Kitchen has a 4.7 rating from 106 Google reviews, categorized as Italian and located on E Davis Blvd in the Davis Islands area of Tampa.

4.7/5
106 reviews
8

Casa Santo Stefano

1607 N 22nd St, Tampa, FL 33605 · website

Casa Santo Stefano is listed as Italian with a 4.6 Google rating drawn from 3,297 reviews, located on N 22nd St in Tampa.

4.6/5
3297 reviews
9

OLIVIA

3601 W Swann Ave, Tampa, FL 33609 · website

OLIVIA carries a 4.6 Google rating with 3,109 reviews, appears in the Italian category and is located on W Swann Ave in Tampa.

4.6/5
3109 reviews
10

Esposito’s Italian Restaurant And Bar

14306 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618 · website

Esposito’s Italian Restaurant And Bar is rated 4.6 on Google from 1,821 reviews, categorized as Italian and located on N Dale Mabry Hwy in Tampa.

4.6/5
1821 reviews
Ranking built with our weighted score (Google rating × how reliable the review count is) across 30 businesses analyzed in Tampa — our methodology.

Frequently asked questions

How should I choose an Italian restaurant in Tampa?

Look at recent reviews and overall rating, consider the number of reviews to gauge reliability, and check the restaurant’s location and hours. Also review photos and menu items when available to match the restaurant’s offerings to your preferences.

What should I check before making a reservation?

Confirm opening hours, reservation policies, and whether they accept calls or online bookings; also ask about seating options if you have accessibility or group-size needs. During busy times, making a reservation in advance reduces wait times.

How much should I expect to spend at a typical Italian restaurant?

Prices vary by style and location, from casual pasta-focused spots to full-service dining. Check menus online or call ahead to get a sense of price ranges before you go.

How is this ranking determined?

This list is derived from Google review data using a Bayesian approach that weights average rating by the number of reviews to favor businesses with both high scores and meaningful review counts. It was updated for 2026 and includes only establishments listed as Italian on Google.

Scroll to Top