Home › Business Services › Insurance broker
The 10 Best Insurance Brokers in Tampa (2026)
We ranked Tampa insurance brokers using a transparent, data-driven approach: a Bayesian-weighted score based on current Google ratings and review totals, updated for 2026. That method balances average scores with the number of local reviews so highly rated firms with meaningful feedback rise to the top. Tampa’s insurance needs range from coastal homeowner concerns to urban auto policies, so local experience and client volume are useful signals when researching coverage options. These short profiles highlight which agencies stand out on Google and provide a quick starting point for getting quotes and asking targeted questions.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a insurance broker in Tampa?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
Seibert Insurance Agency
Seibert Insurance Agency comes out on top by combining a perfect 5.0 Google rating with the largest review count in our set (614 reviews), which the Bayesian weighting rewards. That blend of an impeccable average and substantial local feedback gives it the highest overall score. Listed as an Insurance agency and located on Ehrlich Road in Tampa, its ranking is driven strictly by the publicly available review data.
The full ranking
Lawley Professional Insurance Services
Lawley Professional Insurance Services is rated 5.0 with 467 reviews and appears as an Insurance agency, located on Carrollwood Village Run in the Carrollwood area of Tampa.
467 reviews
Florida Insurance Solutions
Florida Insurance Solutions carries a 5.0 Google rating based on 174 reviews and is listed as an Insurance agency at 114 E Davis Blvd #7 in Tampa.
174 reviews
Enter Insurance
Enter Insurance is a 5.0-rated Insurance agency with 83 reviews, shown at 1412 W Waters Ave Ste 201 in Tampa.
83 reviews
GreatFlorida Insurance: Mike Polivchak
GreatFlorida Insurance: Mike Polivchak has a 4.9 Google rating from 539 reviews and is classified as an Insurance agency at 4034 W Hillsborough Ave in Tampa.
539 reviews
Webb Insurance Group
Webb Insurance Group is listed as a Home insurance agency with a 4.9 rating across 537 reviews; the office is on S Dale Mabry Hwy in Tampa.
537 reviews
Crown Insurance Group, Inc.
Crown Insurance Group, Inc. posts a 4.9 Google score with 537 reviews and is categorized as an Insurance agency at 6903 Gunn Hwy in Tampa.
537 reviews
Most Insurance
Most Insurance shows a 4.9 rating from 347 reviews and is listed specifically as an Auto insurance agency at 3708 W Bay to Bay Blvd in Tampa.
347 reviews
Ric Cave: Allstate Insurance
Ric Cave: Allstate Insurance carries a 4.9 Google rating with 309 reviews and is listed as an Insurance agency at 7755 W Waters Ave in Tampa.
309 reviews
Brier Grieves Insurance
Brier Grieves Insurance holds a 4.9 score from 214 reviews and is categorized as an Insurance agency at 3617 Henderson Blvd in Tampa.
214 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How should I choose an insurance broker in Tampa?
Start by checking online reviews and the broker’s Google rating, then confirm licenses and affiliations. Compare at least two or three brokers on the same lines of coverage, ask about carrier options, and request clear explanations of fees and coverage differences before deciding.
What does working with an insurance broker typically cost?
Costs vary: some brokers are paid by insurer commissions while others charge client fees for advisory work. Always ask up front how the broker is compensated and get any fee or commission arrangement in writing so you can compare total costs.
What should I check before hiring a broker?
Verify the broker’s state license, ask which insurers they represent, and request references or recent client examples for the coverage you need. Also review policy terms carefully—limits, exclusions, deductibles—and confirm who handles claims assistance.
How was this ranking created and why trust it?
The list is based on Google review data processed with a Bayesian-weighted score that balances average rating and review volume, updated for 2026. It’s a quick way to surface firms that combine strong ratings with meaningful local feedback, but you should contact brokers directly to confirm fit and services.